Finding the 12 Best White American Cheese Substitute in 2023

Written By 

Table of Contents

In the world of cooking and cheese aficionados, white American cheese holds a special place. Its creamy texture and mild flavor make it a favorite for sandwiches, burgers, and dips. However, whether you’re lactose intolerant or simply looking for a change, finding the right white American cheese substitute can be a game-changer in your recipes. In this article, we’ll delve into the world of cheese substitutes and help you uncover the perfect alternative.



White American cheese has been a staple in American cuisine for generations. Its versatility and melting properties make it a top choice for dishes like grilled cheese sandwiches and macaroni and cheese. However, dietary restrictions, preferences, and ethical concerns have led many people to seek alternatives. Fortunately, there are plenty of options available that can replicate the creamy goodness of white American cheese without compromising on taste or texture.

Exploring White American Cheese Substitutes

When it comes to choosing a white American cheese substitute, there’s no shortage of options. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most popular alternatives:


Swiss Cheese

Description: Swiss cheese is a semi-hard cheese known for its pale yellow color and distinctive holes (known as “eyes”). It has a mild, nutty, and slightly sweet flavor with a smooth and creamy texture.

cheese, cheesy, closeup-1238395.jpg
Swiss Cheese

Best Uses: Swiss cheese is a versatile cheese that works well in sandwiches, particularly in the classic Reuben or ham and Swiss sandwich. It’s also a popular choice for melting in fondues and adding to omelets.

Provolone Cheese

Description: Provolone cheese comes in two varieties: mild and sharp. It’s an Italian semi-hard cheese with a pale yellow to white color. Mild provolone has a creamy, buttery flavor, while sharp provolone has a stronger, tangier taste.

block, cheese, cheesy-1238386.jpg
Provolone Cheese

Best Uses: Mild provolone is perfect for sandwiches and burgers, while sharp provolone adds depth to pasta dishes, salads, and antipasto platters.

Muenster Cheese

Description: Muenster cheese is a semi-soft cheese with a pale orange rind and a white interior. It has a mild and slightly tangy flavor, along with a creamy texture that melts well.

Best Uses: Muenster cheese is an excellent choice for grilled sandwiches, especially when combined with other ingredients like ham or turkey. It’s also a great addition to macaroni and cheese.

Cheddar Cheese

Description: Cheddar cheese is a firm cheese with a wide range of flavors, from mild to sharp, depending on aging. It has a creamy texture and can range in color from white to orange.

Best Uses: Cheddar cheese is incredibly versatile and can be used in a variety of dishes, including grilled cheese sandwiches, casseroles, and as a topping for baked potatoes.

Mozzarella Cheese

Description: Mozzarella cheese is a soft and stretchy cheese with a mild and slightly sweet flavor. It’s available in various forms, including fresh and shredded.

Best Uses: Mozzarella cheese is the go-to choice for making pizza, lasagna, and caprese salads. Its exceptional melting properties also make it a favorite for stuffed crust pizza.

Pepper Jack Cheese

Description: Pepper Jack cheese is a semi-soft cheese with bits of spicy jalapeño peppers and other hot chili peppers. It has a creamy texture and a mildly spicy flavor.

Best Uses: Pepper Jack cheese adds a kick to burgers, sandwiches, and quesadillas. It’s perfect for those who enjoy a touch of heat in their dishes.

Gouda Cheese

Description: Gouda cheese is a semi-soft to hard cheese with a pale yellow to orange rind. It has a mild, slightly sweet, and nutty flavor, with a creamy texture.

Best Uses: Gouda cheese is a versatile cheese that works well on cheese platters, in sandwiches, and for melting in soups and macaroni and cheese.

Blue Cheese

Description: Blue cheese is known for its distinct, tangy flavor and characteristic blue veins. It’s made by introducing specific molds into the cheese during production.

Best Uses: Blue cheese is perfect for adding a bold and unique flavor to salads, steaks, and dressings. Its creamy texture pairs well with fruits like pears and figs.

Brie Cheese

Description: Brie cheese is soft and creamy with a mild, buttery taste. It has a white, edible rind and a rich, luxurious texture.

Best Uses: Brie is excellent for spreading on crackers, pairing with wine, or baking in pastry for a decadent appetizer.

Havarti Cheese

Description: Havarti cheese is semi-soft with small irregular holes. It has a mild, buttery flavor and a creamy texture.

Best Uses: Havarti is great for melting in grilled cheese sandwiches, topping burgers, or serving on cheese platters with fruits and nuts.

Feta Cheese

Description: Feta cheese is a crumbly and tangy cheese made from sheep’s milk. It has a salty and slightly sour taste.

Best Uses: Feta is a staple in Mediterranean cuisine, ideal for salads, pastries, and as a topping for dishes like Greek salad and pizza.

Parmesan Cheese

Description: Parmesan cheese is hard and aged, known for its intense, salty, and nutty flavor. It’s often grated or shaved.

Best Uses: Parmesan adds depth to pasta dishes, salads, and soups. It’s also perfect for sprinkling over roasted vegetables and risotto.

Cooking with White American Cheese Substitutes

Now that you’ve identified some suitable alternatives, let’s explore how to use them in your favorite recipes. Whether you’re making a classic grilled cheese sandwich or a cheesy pasta dish, these substitutes can step in seamlessly.

Grilled Cheese Perfection

There’s something undeniably comforting about a grilled cheese sandwich. To achieve the same gooey goodness without white American cheese, opt for Swiss or provolone cheese slices. These options melt beautifully and pair wonderfully with a variety of bread and toppings.

Creamy Mac and Cheese

Macaroni and cheese is a beloved classic, and you can maintain its creamy essence by using Muenster or cheddar cheese in your recipe. The result? A velvety, cheesy sauce that coats every noodle.

Burger Bliss

White American cheese is a staple in the world of burgers. To recreate that iconic melt, try using cheddar or a plant-based cheese slice on your next burger patty. The flavors will meld together perfectly.

Cheese Dips and Fondue

For cheese dips and fondue, a homemade cheese sauce can work wonders. Experiment with various plant-based cheese alternatives to create a rich and creamy dip for your favorite snacks.

White American Cheese Substitute

Now that we’ve explored a range of alternatives and their applications, you can confidently make the switch to a white American cheese substitute that suits your taste and dietary preferences. Whether you opt for a traditional cheese variety or a plant-based alternative, you’ll find that your favorite dishes can still be deliciously cheesy.

RankSubstitute CheeseDescriptionBest Uses
1Swiss CheeseSemi-hard cheese with a mild, nutty flavor and creamy texture.Sandwiches, Melting, Fondues, Omelets
2Provolone CheeseItalian semi-hard cheese with mild or sharp varieties.Sandwiches, Burgers, Pasta, Antipasto
3Muenster CheeseSemi-soft cheese with a mild, slightly tangy taste and creamy texture.Grilled Sandwiches, Macaroni and Cheese
4Cheddar CheeseFirm cheese with a wide range of flavors, from mild to sharp.Grilled Cheese, Casseroles, Baked Potatoes
5Mozzarella CheeseSoft, stretchy cheese with a mild, sweet flavor.Pizza, Lasagna, Caprese Salad, Stuffed Crust Pizza
6Pepper Jack CheeseSemi-soft cheese with bits of spicy peppers and a mildly spicy flavor.Burgers, Sandwiches, Quesadillas
7Gouda CheeseSemi-soft to hard cheese with a mild, nutty flavor and creamy texture.Cheese Platters, Sandwiches, Melting in Soups
8Blue CheeseDistinct, tangy cheese with blue veins and a creamy texture.Salads, Steaks, Dressings
9Brie CheeseSoft and creamy cheese with a mild, buttery taste and edible rind.Crackers, Baking, Wine Pairing
10Havarti CheeseSemi-soft cheese with small holes, mild, buttery flavor.Grilled Cheese, Burger Topping, Cheese Platters
11Feta CheeseCrumbly and tangy cheese made from sheep’s milk.Mediterranean Dishes, Salads, Pizza
12Parmesan CheeseHard and aged cheese with an intense, salty, nutty flavor.Pasta, Salads, Soups, Roasted Vegetables
Substitute Cheese


In your culinary journey, discovering the perfect white American cheese substitute opens up a world of possibilities. Whether you choose a classic cheese or a plant-based option, you can continue enjoying your favorite cheesy dishes while accommodating dietary needs and preferences. Embrace the versatility of these substitutes and elevate your cooking to new heights.


Can I use mozzarella cheese as a white American cheese substitute?

Yes, mozzarella cheese can be used as a substitute, especially in recipes that require a melty and creamy texture.

Are there low-fat alternatives to white American cheese?

Certainly! Look for low-fat versions of the suggested substitutes like Swiss, provolone, or cheddar cheese.

How can I make a plant-based white American cheese substitute at home?

To make a homemade plant-based substitute, blend soaked cashews, nutritional yeast, garlic powder, and a pinch of turmeric for color and flavor.

Are there any white American cheese substitutes that are lactose-free?

Yes, many of the alternatives mentioned, especially the plant-based options, are naturally lactose-free.

Can I freeze white American cheese substitutes?

While some substitutes freeze better than others, it’s generally recommended to use them fresh for the best taste and texture.

Are white American cheese substitutes suitable for people with nut allergies?

If you have a nut allergy, it’s best to opt for non-nut-based substitutes like cheddar or plant-based options made from soy.

Author Box

Yaseen Zaman

Yaseen Zaman

A dedicated enthusiast and expert in the art of Bonsai. My journey with these miniature wonders of nature began many years ago, and it has since transformed into a profound passion that I wish to share with others. Throughout my blog, you will discover the depth of my knowledge and my unique insights into the cultivation and care of Bonsai trees. From shaping techniques to watering tips, expect a treasure trove of Bonsai wisdom that I've gathered over the years. Join me as we delve into the intricate world of Bonsai, celebrating both their aesthetic beauty and the peace they bring to our lives.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Want to keep up with our blog?

Get our most valuable tips right inside your inbox, once per month!

Related Posts